Madeira Mondays: Yellow Fever in Colonial Philadelphia

“The horrors of this memorable affliction were extensive and heart rending.” – Samuel Breck, 18th century merchant, on Philadelphia’s 1793 yellow fever epidemic

In mid August, 1793, the first Philadelphian died from what would become a devastating epidemic of yellow fever. By the end of October, the city had lost nearly 5,000 people – 10% of the entire population.

In the last Madeira Mondays, we looked at 18th century medicine in general – how people thought diseases spread and what they did to try and fight them – and this week we’re going to be diving into how that looked in practice with one specific and fascinating example: Philadelphia’s infamous yellow fever outbreak.

What was the disease? Who were the major players trying to combat and contain it? And how did it change the city afterwards?

(This post was also inspired by my reading of Fever, 1793 by the fantastic young adult author Laurie Halse Anderson, so if you’ve not checked out that book review, you can have a look here!)

First of all, what was/is yellow fever and how is it spread?

It’s an infectious viral disease, characterized by the disturbing color changes of the eyes and skin (to yellow, thus the name) and purple blotches under the skin from internal bleeding. And it’s spread by certain mosquitos! The only problem is: nobody knew it was spread by mosquitos until 1881. So when the disease struck colonial Philadelphia hard in the summer of 1793, they didn’t know to blame the little bugs breeding in the stagnant, muddy swamps.

Instead, Dr Rush, one of the city’s leading physicians and signer of the Declaration of Independence (fun fact), blamed it on the predominate medical theory of the time: miasmas or bad smells (which I talk about in more detail in my last post!). Rush pointed to rotting vegetables and coffee left out in the wharfs, general bad sewage and uncleanliness in the city.

Many others at the time were also quick to lay blame at the feet of the refugees fleeing the Haitian slave revolt. (Which is a very interesting story in itself. I remember giving an oral report on the Haitian Revolution, in probably very terrible french, for my high school French class. Basically, an army of slaves, led by Toussiant L’Ouverture, wrested control away from the colony’s white rulers and Haiti become the first black-led nation in the West. It’s been a long time since I read about this in any detail, but let me know if you want to know more!)

I’ve read conflicting accounts of whether or not this bout of yellow fever was actually brought to Philadelphia by these refugees, of various races, arriving to Philadelphia. But we do know that it was/is definitely spread by mosquito bites. And there’s a clever nod to this at the beginning of Halse Anderson’s book where the main character describes ‘a mosquito whining in my left ear.’

How was it treated?

Benjamin Rush again relied on conventional medical knowledge of the time period and he bled people (more on this in my last post) to get rid of the ‘pestilence’ in their bodies. This likely did kill people, on accident of course. He also gave them medicines to make them poop, again to get rid of the pestilence, and he advocated for keeping the city clean (believing the disease spread through foul air).

French doctors in the city, however, didn’t want to bleed people. Instead, they suggested rest, fluids, and plenty of fresh air. That ‘cure’ still holds water by modern standards, and I’m guessing these methods saved a lot of people’s lives in the city! Yay, French doctors!!

Dr. Rush’s treatments may have been harmful, but his presence in the city and dedication to medicine was actually very brave. He didn’t flee, as many did (including Washington and Jefferson, who were there for Congress – Philly was the capital at the time). Rush felt it was his duty to stay behind and help the city as best he could.

Dr Benjamin Rush, accessed via Wikipedia here

Rush also held the (false) belief that African Americans couldn’t get the disease, so called upon the Free African Society (which was an aid organization to help African Americans in the city) to tend to the sick. Under the leadership of Richard Allen and Absalom Jones (founders of the Free African Society), society members worked tirelessly tending to the sick of all races. They nursed people day and night, they drove carts, dug graves. The sights that Jones and Allen recall of the city during this period were terrible, full of gloom and fear (and seem eerily familiar to us now, living during a pandemic):

“at this time the dread that prevailed over people’s minds was so general, that it was a rare instance to see one neighbor visit another, and even friends when they met in the streets were afraid of each other, much less would they admit into their houses.”

Despite Rush’s theory, of course African Americans could get the disease and sadly some of these people did die in service to the city’s relief efforts.

After the epidemic was over, Free African Society members were attacked in a pamphlet published by local printer Matthew Carey, who alleged that the black society members had been corrupt: stealing from the sick and overcharging for burials. The Mayor, Matthew Clarkson, responded in the city’s newspaper, refuting the charges and defending the work of the Free African Society. Jones and Allen wrote their own pamphlet in response to these charges too, chronicling what their society had done for the city: A Narrative of the Proceedings of the Black People, During the Late Awful Calamity in Philadelphia, in the Year 1793: and a Refutation of Some Censures, Thrown Upon Them in Some Late Publications. (You can read this pamphlet here).

Absalom Jones, painted by the same talented fellow, Peale, that did the Dr. Rush’s portrait above. Jones was a fascinating guy: he was born a slave in Delaware, won his freedom, went on to help found the Free African Society, and was the first black Episcopal priest.

How did it end?

Right now, in early 2021, we’re all wondering how the Covid-19 pandemic will ‘end’ and when life will return to normal. But instead of waiting on their population to become vaccinated, what ended the three months of hell that Philadelphia experienced in 1793 was actually: cold weather.

With the first frost, the mosquitos died out and the transmission stopped.

Although it’s important to note that yellow fever is still around, just not in the USA because in the 1930’s, drum roll…we got a vaccine for it. Yay vaccines! It does still exist in parts of sub-Saharan Africa and South America though.

What were the LASTING effects?

Of course there were nightmarish personal consequences, which are difficult for us to fully imagine. After weeks of seeing carts rolling by filled with the dead, many children orphaned, streets deserted, food scarce, people were surely traumatized and grief stricken. Many of them had lost family and friends.

But in the city as a whole, it did lead to more strictly enforced sanitation laws and a whole new water  system (many thought that bad water could be a cause of the fever). So some general good things did come of it even if, again, they hadn’t yet correctly identified the root cause of disease transmission.

*

So that’s just a peak into an interesting and quite harrowing moment in American history. Hope these last three posts were an interesting look at medicine and disease in 18th century America. There are so many more topics I could go into here (we’ve never talked about small pox, I don’t think, on this blog and that was a major issue at this time).

I think it’s so interesting to learn about how historical people thought of and handled disease, especially now with our current pandemic still very much alive and well.

Did you enjoy (maybe ‘enjoy’ is the wrong word…) reading about yellow fever in Philadelphia? What other aspects of early American health and hygiene would you like to know about? I get a lot of questions when I’m working at The Georgian House about baths and personal grooming, so I’m happy to talk about that! A bit of a lighter subject.

As always, THANK YOU for reading, and stay safe!

‘Madeira Mondays’ is a series of blog posts exploring 18th century history and historical fiction. Follow the blog for a new post every other Monday and thanks for reading!

Recommended Further reading:

  • Fever, 1793 by Laurie Halse Anderson (published in the early 2000s, this fast-paced and vivid little YA novel feels especially relevant now)
  • ‘Philadelphia Under Seige: Yellow Fever of 1793’ by Samuel A. Gum (published on the Pennsylvania Center for the Book’s website, a short and snappy little article, where a lot of the information in this post came from. It’s very excited about Dr. Rush and his achievements, maybe a bit too much in my eyes, but still makes for a good overview!)
  • A Narrative of the Proceedings of the Black People, During the Late Awful Calamity in Philadelphia, in the Year 1793: and a Refutation of Some Censures, Thrown Upon Them in Some Late Publications can be read online here
  • More information on the Haitian Slave Revolt is here
  • The wonderful Ben Franklin’s World podcast released an episode about yellow fever in early America here. (This is a BRILLIANT podcast, interviewing top notch historians who are leaders in their field. The interviewer, Liz Covart, who I’ve met and is delightful, always asks great questions and makes it all really accessible! Recommended!!)

 

4 thoughts on “Madeira Mondays: Yellow Fever in Colonial Philadelphia

  1. Nancy says:

    So interesting! I love hearing about and imaging people’s lives at that time in history. Thanks for the well researched and well written blog!

    FYI – My great aunt, Louisiana “Lizzy” Nussbaum, died in one of the yellow fever epidemics in New Orleans.
    Here’s an interesting post about the epidemics and related racism there: https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2018/10/31/415535913/how-yellow-fever-turned-new-orleans-into-the-city-of-the-dead

    Liked by 1 person

    • Carly Brown says:

      Thanks for reading Nancy! And for sending that NPR post – I enjoyed listening to it, and wasn’t aware of how much yellow fever had devastated New Orleans too throughout the 19th and even the beginning of the 20th centuries (including your own family and your great aunt – wow). I guess given the surrounding swamps, it’s not surprising it was a perfect breeding spot for the mosquitos that transmitted it!

      I hadn’t known (but I guess wasn’t surprised by) the fact that this myth that black people couldn’t get yellow fever continued into the 19th century and was used as another justification for slavery. Not surprised, but sad to learn about.

      I do think it’s very interesting to learn about people’s lives during other times of extreme epidemics and disease outbreaks. All of this made me all the more grateful that there is a yellow fever vaccine!! 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s